All SHP News News June 14, 2021

Passing the Test: A Model-Based Analysis of Safe School-Reopening Strategies

The COVID-19 pandemic has provoked historic educational disruptions. In an effort to inform public policy on the school re-opening debate, a team of researchers developed a model to simulate transmission in elementary and high school communities, as well as household interactions.
A young girl heads back to school with a mask.
Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

The United Nations estimates that more than 168 million children missed out on in-classroom learning as schools remained largely shut for almost an entire year due to coronavirus lockdowns. And in the United States, all 50 states recommended or mandated public school closures, affecting at least 124,000 schools and 55.1 million students.

As of April 2021, about 40% of U.S. public school students were still unable to attend schools in person full time — leading public health officials, parents and educators to worry that school children would fall behind both academically and developmentally.

In an effort to inform public policy on the school re-opening debate, a team of researchers at Stanford University, Harvard University, Massachusetts General Hospital and University of Maryland School of Medicine developed a model to simulate transmission in elementary and high school communities, as well as household interactions.

In a study published June 8 in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the researchers found that with controlled transmission of COVID-19 in communities and adherence to school-based prevention measures, elementary schools can open with few in-school transmissions. For high schools, and for elementary schools in communities with high COVID-19 rates, regular screening of students and staff without symptoms can reduce risk.

“Debates around school reopening have been incredibly contentious, because schooling has such central importance to students, families and society, but also because evidence on safety in schools during the pandemic has been incomplete and sometimes contradictory,” said Stanford Health Policy’s Joshua Salomon, a co-author of the study. For example, the researchers noted that many studies have found little secondary transmission in schools — yet coronavirus clusters in schools have also been documented in other well-regarded studies.

Despite the contradictions, there is little debate over the benefits of in-person education. There have been reports of high levels of absenteeism in the last year, increased depression, anxiety and thoughts of suicide. “Beyond educational and mental health outcomes, opening schools also improves access to social services for children and labor market outcomes for working parents, especially women,” the co-authors write.

“Returning to safe, full-time in-person schooling for every student in the fall – and keeping schools open and safe – should be a national priority. Our main motivation in undertaking this study was to define the conditions and actions that are needed to make that possible,” said Salomon, PhD, a professor of medicine and senior fellow at the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies.

The researchers simulated settings based on average U.S. classrooms, with elementary schools of 638 students from 500 households, and high schools of 1,451 students from 1,225 households. They allowed for daily local incidence to vary between 1 and 100 cases per 100,000 students, faculty, staff and adult household members. They then focused on the risk that transmission would occur on a school campus and spread to household members — a less explored area of research.

They found that community transmission rates are major drivers of in-school transmission. Whereas elementary schools are likely ‘mirrors’ of these community rates, high schools may be ‘amplifiers’ of community transmission. However, preventive measures in schools, such as masking, distancing, and ventilation, can strongly counter the impact of high community transmission. If schools have the resources to implement mitigation measures well, these measures not only reduce the number of infections transmitted in schools on average, but also substantially reduce the chance of worst-case outcomes, including large outbreaks.

“We predict that most in-school transmission will occur in the classroom during sustained contact, and interventions that reduce classroom transmission can be highly effective, including distancing, masking, or reducing class sizes,” the researchers concluded. The paper emphasizes that, even in the event of a fall COVID-19 resurgence, staff vaccination markedly decreases risk of transmission and illness.

The study also reports the potential benefits of weekly screening for students and staff without symptoms. Screening has two major benefits — both reducing the risk that people who are infected will come to school and infect others, as well as providing better real-time information on how much transmission is occurring in schools. As the authors note, data from screening programs can provide a more direct and current guide to local decisions than broader measures of cases rates in the community.

Salomon and his colleagues look ahead to the continuing rollout of COVID-19 vaccination for adults and teenagers to provide a major boost to prospects for safe reopening in the fall, at the same time that they acknowledge concerns over new, more virulent variants of COVID-19 that have been spreading widely in Britain, India and other areas.

“This shift highlights the urgent need for data and underscores the added value of routine asymptomatic screening,” the authors write. “Tradeoffs are inevitable between school disruption, risk for in-school transmission, and resources required to implement reopening strategies.”

Joshua Salomon

Professor of Medicine
Measurement and evaluation of health interventions and policies.
Joshua Salomon of Stanford Health Policy

read more

COVID-19 Vaccine Illustration

Encouraging Sign: Many California Prisoners Willing To Be Vaccinated

Two-thirds of the nearly 100,000 incarcerated residents in California's 35 prisons were offered COVID-19 vaccines and 66.5% of those accepted at least one dose, according to a new Stanford study — although uptake varied across different groups.
A Simulation of a World COVID-19 Map

A Story One Year in the Telling: the Stanford COVID Modeling Project

The Stanford-CIDE Coronavirus Simulation Model was established in the frightening days when the world was realizing a deadly virus in China would become a pandemic. A look at its accomplishments and projects one year later.
African American gets vaccinated

Mapping the Inequality of COVID-19 Household Exposure and Transmission Risk

Communities of color may be most susceptible to low coverage due to long-standing disparities in healthcare, mistrust fueled by a history of exploitation in clinical trials, and other structural risk factors, according to new research by Stanford Health Policy.